| 2
| Sean Stimpfel
| Jr.
| LHP | Jackson, NJ / Jackson Memorial | Criminal Justice |
| 3
| Mike Judd
| Rf.
| INF | Flanders, NJ / Mt. Olive | Undecided |
| 4
| Anderson Minyetty
| Jr.
| OF | Jersey City, NJ / Hudson County Prep | General Business |
| 5
| Emilio Fernandez
| So.
| OF | Paterson, NJ / Paterson East Side | Criminal Justice |
| 6
| Edwin Cruz
| So.
| OF | Newark, NJ / Newark East Side | English |
| 7
| Alex Sepulveda
| Jr.
| C | Newark, NJ / Newark East Side | Business Management |
| 8
| Kevin Baumiller
| Rf.
| RHP | West Palm Beach, FL / John I Leonard | Undecided |
| 9
| Anthony Fratto
| Jr.
| 1B/DH | Newburgh, NY / Wallkill High School | Sociology/Criminal Justice |
| 10
| Edgardo Fernandez
| So.
| INF | Newark, NJ / Barringer | Biology |
| 11
| Louis Guzman
| Sr.
| RHP | Jersey City, NJ / Hudson County Prep | Accounting |
| 13
| Christian Rosa
| Jr.
| INF | Perth Amboy, NJ / Perth Amboy | Criminal Justice |
| 14
| David Ricci
| Jr.
| RHP | Jackson, NJ / Jackson Memorial | Business Management |
| 15
| Jose Lebron
| Sr.
| OF | Hicksville, NY / Saint Dominic's | Allied Health Technology |
| 16
| Brad Smith
| So.
| RHP | Wanaque, NJ / Lakeland | Special Education/ History |
| 18
| Alberto Ruiz
| Jr.
| OF | Edison, NJ / Edison | Criminal Justice |
| 19
| Edwin Pagan
| Sr.
| INF | Burlington, NJ / Burlington | Business Administration/ Marketing |
| 21
| Jon Walsh
| Sr.
| RHP | Saddle Brook, NJ / Saddle Brook | Accounting |
| 23
| Anthony Addone
| Jr.
| UT | Milltown, NJ / Spotswood | Business Management |
| 24
| John Whitley
| Jr.
| RHP | Lake Mary, FL / Lake Mary Prep | Business Administration |
| 25
| John Vilichka
| So.
| LHP | Port Reading, NJ / Woodbridge | Secondary Education |
| 27
| Manny Lopez
| Sr.
| INF | Newark, NJ / Seton Hall Prep | Business Management |
| 28
| Steven Godowski
| Jr.
| RHP | Sayerville, NJ / Bishop George Ahr | Business Management |
| 30
| Matthew Snyder
| Sr.
| LHP | Bensalem, PA / Bensalem | Digital Video |
| 31
| Andres Machuca
| Fr.
| LHP | Bronx, NY / South Bronx | Business Management |
| 33
| Mike Alfano
| Fr.
| C | Old Bridge, NJ / Cardinal McCarrick | Education |
| 34
| Delroy Cox
| Sr.
| OF | Brooklyn, NY / Midwood | Marketing |
| 36
| Rafael Cruz
| So.
| RHP | Jersey City, NJ / St. Mary's | Criminal Justice |
| 37
| Mike Monaco
| So.
| C | Avenel, NJ / Colonia | Education |
| 38
| Joe Knazek
| So.
| C | Medford, NJ / Collingswood | Education |
| 39
| Michael Fratto
| So.
| RHP | Newburgh, NY / Walkill | Undecided |
| 40
| Louis Castillo
| Jr.
| RHP | Elizabeth, NJ / Roselle Catholic | Business |